PHOTOS FROM A SIMULATION

Introduction

This website will enable a CRS Ambassador chapter or a social justice class to create a simulation to educate participants on the issues facing refugees, especially unaccompanied minors. These children or teens are fleeing gang violence, domestic abuse, and drug cartels in their home countries of Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador. In a 25-minute interaction, participants experience:

  • reenactments of the type of push factors like gang threats that drive unaccompanied minors to flee their homes for safety;
  • reflections on root causes of the migration, with explanations on what is being done to address “push” factors by agencies such as CRS;
  • reenactments of what happens to minors when they are detained at the US-Mexico border. Some may be put in detention centers, others deported, and some reunited with family in the States.
  • explanations, through the lens of Catholic Social Teaching, of proposals for what needs to be done to improve the treatment of the young people, the legal process that young people must undergo to prove their case as refugees, as well as options for what might happen to the minors;
  • opportunities to engage in advocacy, including a range of options from social media to petitions to advocacy emails; and
  • reflection and prayer to deepen the participants’ commitment to solidarity.

The four headings below (LEARN, PLAN, REFLECT, ADVOCATE) will give you essential background on the issue, instructions on how to set up the simulation, and resources for reflection, prayer, and advocacy.


TO LEARN MORE, CLICK ON THE FOUR HEADERS BELOW.

Steps To Prepare This Simulation

LEARN

We have broken down what you need to learn into 6 categories.

PLAN

We have provided a very specific model of what this simulation might look like.

REFLECT

While the simulation is action-filled, we set aside a time and space for personal reflection.

ADVOCATE

It is essential that we make our voices heard on this issue. Here’s some ways to advocate.


Video of simulation at Cabrini College

This 15-minute video shows how one group of college students presented a simulation of what it might be like for unaccompanied minor children to attempt to come to the United States to escape gang violence in their home country.


LEARN

We have broken down what you need to learn into 6 categories.

The refugee crisis has received a lot of attention. Unaccompanied minors from Central America, Syrian refugees, Rohingya refugees, and more have added up to the largest movement of displaced people since World War II. However, the sheer numbers and complexity of causes may lead to people tuning out the daily headlines. We have curated a list of resources we found helpful.

Our Cabrini CRS Ambassadors divided up into groups and each group become knowledgeable about one aspect of the refugee crisis and then explained what they learned to the other groups.

First, start with this excellent overview video explanation by Juan Sheenan of CRS. Juan is the CRS Country Representative for Honduras.

1. Why kids are leaving their homes (Push Factors)

2. The journey

3. The border

4. Detention

5. Deportation

6. Hoping to Reunite with Family in the U.S.



PLAN

We give very specific information on how we developed our simulation.
This is a suggested floor plan for the simulation.

Outline and set-up

  • 1. PARTICIPANTS ENTER
  • At the Identity Station at the ENTRY, the leader at the door explains the journey from three different countries, Honduras, Guatemala, and El Salvador. All will then go through Mexico, until they get to the border.
  • At the Identity Station at the start, the leader assigns each participant an identity, gives each a sum of money, tells them to read their identity, and to proceed on the journey. PLAY VIDEO.
  • 2. GANGS:
  • The participants travel through different countries in the Triangle into
  • Mexico and ride on the train called La Bestia.
  • During this time, participants will be attacked by gang members, who will steal from them and intimidate them. (See video)
  • Finally participants reach the U.S. – Mexico Border.
  • DEBRIEF 1
  • Before they go to the Judge, it is important for someone to interpret the journey with the participants (see video). She then tells them to go before
  • 3. a JUDGE
  • The Judge can assign three different outcomes (See Video)
    • Deportation
    • Reuniting with family
    • Detention Center (See Video)
  • DEBRIEF 2
  • After each participant leaves their assigned outcome, it is important to have someone interpret the possible outcomes a child could experience. The three outcomes could be deportation, detention, or family unification. Here Katie explains these three ways a child’s life could have turned. (See video)
  • 4. REFLECT
  • Each participant then goes to the Prayer Reflection area and finally to
  • 5. ADVOCATE
  • the Advocacy area.

Supplies needed

Here is a list of supplies you need to create Refugees Seeking Safety:

  • Journey:
    • Colored Coded Index Cards
    • 6ft Table
    • Multi Colored Duck Tape
    • Fake Money
    • Traffic Cones to create obstacles
    • Minimum Number of People needed: 1 as the the person to greet participants, 1 gang member
  • Judge:
    • Gavel/Robe
    • Lectern
    • Number of People: 1
  • Detention Center:
    • Cot/Mattress
    • Foil Blanket (Amazon)
    • Fair Trade Tortillas
    • Rope/Chains
    • Number of People: 1
  • Family Reunification:
    • Circle Table/Chairs
    • Snacks or Cookies
    • Number of People: 1
  • Deportation Area:
    • Chairs
    • Number of People: 1
  • Advocacy Area:
    • 3 Tables/Chairs
    • Postcards/Fliers (Getting your point across, links, resources)
    • Posters with Pictures
      • “Refugees Seeking Safety”
      • “I Understand What It Means to Be a Refugee Seeking Safety”
    • Bracelets or Something they can take away from this.
    • Signed Letters to Congressmen, Senators.
    • Number of People: 4, depending on number of participants
  • Prayer Reflection Area:
    • Table
    • Mounted Pictures
    • Candles
    • Reflection Booklet
    • Number of People: 1

Participants receive identities of minors at the start

Script: (see video)

Hello and Welcome to Refugees Seeking Safety.

What you are about to experience is something that kids, teens and young adults in Central America go through everyday. Starting in their home countries, they flee towards the United States due to gang violence. What we are going to do today, is give you an identity card of a child who has actually made this journey before; how they traveled, reasons why they left, and what happened to them if they reached the U.S. We are going to give you a taste of what it is like to be an Unaccompanied Minor.

(Give out Identity Cards and Money)

When you are finished reading your Identity Cards, you may begin your journey ahead.

(Show them the path they are going to need to go to)

Identities are printed on colored cards. 6 different colors for the 6 identities.

Each of the cards they are handed have a different identity and country of origin. Based on these backstories each person’s journey will be slightly different. Here is a PDF file with all the six identities you can download and print.

  1. Daniel Penado Zowala
    Age: 17
    Country: El Salvador
    Background: Gang members killed his father. The gang members would kill him if he resisted their wishes.
    Journey: However you want
  2. Rosa DeJesus
    Age:18
    Country: El Salvador
    Background: In El Salvador, gangs take young girls, rape them and throw them in a plastic bags.
    Journey:
  3. Kayla Perez
    Age: 15
    Country: Honduras
    Background: Traveled with her 2 children: 18 months, 2 yrs, mother and 3 siblings. She wanted to get away from her father who raped her. Also she fled from gangs.
  4. Chris Omar Rodriguez
    Age: 11
    Country: Honduras
    Background: His father was robbed and murdered by gangs while working as a security guard protecting a food truck.
  5. Cecilia Reyes
    Age: 17
    Country: Guatemala
    Background: This is her 5th time trying, she hired a smuggler to get out of the country to go to the US for freedom.
  6. Maria Nelson
    Age:17
    Country: Guatemala
    Background: She grew up in Guatemala and was abused by her dad. After several attempts, she fled to the US for a better life.

**Note: Many people who attempt this tough journey to the US Border often get turned back. Suggestion: Send some people back to the beginning(their home country).

Gang members

The gang members can have scripts.  But their script is usually ad libbed. (see video)

However the basics of the gang members’ scripts are:

  1. we steal all of your money.
  2. we will beat you up.
  3. we will send you back and force you to try the journey again.

Debrief the journey at the US-Mexico border (see video)

Someone who really understands the entire simulation well should be selected to debrief each participant about the journey.

Once a participant makes the journey through her home country she must travel through Mexico.

  • The people making the journey sit down on crates(4-6).
  • They are riding the train or La Bestia.(This is the train that will get them through most of Mexico.)
  • While on the train, there will be someone talking to them.

Script:

The gang violence you just experienced in your home country doesn’t stop there.  Other outcomes that could happen are you get raped, abused, beaten, or killed.  These young children don’t want to leave their home countries, their families, their friends, their homes. Everything they know is in these countries.  You have now made it to Mexico. You are traveling through Mexico on La Bestia.  You just finish traveling through your home countries. You are lucky enough to even make it out of your home countries with all of the gang violence. However their is more gang violence in Mexico. While traveling through Mexico, the journey takes about 15-20 days. Most of these young children board the train you are on now.  These people spend most of their time on this train.  It is dangerous as you can see. Often times at night gang members will hop on the train and steal people’s money or just ask for their money. If the children don’t have it, the gangs will throw you off.  People get seriously injured on this train. Once off the train, there are rest stops provided by churches where people can spend a night and get food and rest. Then they have to wake up the next morning and face more gang violence. If you are lucky enough to make it through Mexico and not be sent back you arrive at the border while you will await your fate.  That is where you will be heading next.”

While these people are traveling on the train:

There could be a few gang members that pop out as you are speaking to steal their money and even “throw” them off the train.

You could have pictures to show.

The pictures should include:

  1. The countries: to show how truly long this journey is.
  2. The train.
  3. People traveling on the train.
  4. The gang violence in Mexico.
  5. People broken limbs. What people look like after the train.

Legal system at border (The judge)

The Judge determines which of three outcomes is assigned to a participant. The judge does not speak Spanish, while the minors do. No interpreter is provided. A small percentage gets legal representation. If a minor has a lawyer, chances for family unification is vastly higher. (This portion is flexible depending on manpower. You could have all 3 outcomes if you have the people to play the roles. Alternatively, you could have just one, namely the detention center. Te LEARN section has a video of a Detention Center.

There are three outcomes:

  1. Deportation: “I’m not sure why you made this journey. There is no point in you being here. I’m just going to send you back again.” Minors who are deported often are dropped off at the capital city of their country, with no resources to return home. They are prey to the same dangers as when they fled.
  2. Detention: “I don’t speak Spanish. I only speak English. I don’t know what to do with you. See what will happen to you.” The conditions of the detention centers resemble prisons. Read more here. Our video here.
  3. Family reunification in the US: ”You got lucky, you are being reunited with your family. Hope it is what you wanted it to be.” Although this sounds like a good outcome, if you read Enrique’s Journey, you will learn that the reunification has many problems. The parents may have moved on in their lives and may have a new family. The new arrival is another mouth to feed. There may be resentment and anger because of the years of separation.

Debriefing the 3 border outcomes

Again, it is important to have a well-informed leader spend time with each participant debriefing all that happens at the border.

Here is a video of Cabrini’s Katie Briante doing a debrief.



REFLECT

We have a PDF file here of reflections for the simulation. Please download it here.

ADVOCATE

Person standing in front of the advocacy section gives the participants a bracelet and postcard and directs them to the first table.
  • Table 1
    • The person managing the table will ask how the whole experience was. Then they will proceed to ask the participants if they would sign the poster “I Understand What it Means to be a Refugee Seeking Safety” to validate that they understand the simulation. They then tell them that to find out more information on the topic they can visit the links that are on the post card. Then they direct them to the 2nd and 3rd tables.
  • Table 2 and 3
    • At these tables there will be letters to congress for people to read over and write their suggestions, feelings or opinions on the topic in a comment section. These letters will be filled out with the participant’s address on the bottom so the group knows which congressmen to give it to. Also at these tables there will be extra bracelets scattered around as well as pictures of refugees and people lobbying for them around the table. Remember in the end to thank them for coming and send them off to the exit.

There is no official script because this is a station mostly for questions so here are few talking points to be familiar with.

Talking Points for the Tables

Write to Congress

  • We urge you to reach out to Congress so they can help make a difference with the violence, lack of opportunity and desire to reunite with families in the United States. There are a number of organizations that advocate for more just laws to assist refugees.
    • One is Jesuit Refugee Service. The link to their advocacy page is here.
    • Another is the International Rescue Committee. Their advocacy link.
    • Both sites
      • ask for your name and address and route your message to the proper lawmaker.
      • Include a comment section for people to add their own thoughts on the matter
  • Educate yourself more on the issue. Always check ConfrontGlobalPoverty.org for updates.
    • Current campaign is called Bring Home Dignity for Migrants.
    • Become more informed with the issues around the world
    • Stay informed with the issue and how CRS is working with the people to find a better way to live
    • Open your eyes
  • You might also consider
    • Donating.
      • Why give money?
        • Organizations like CRS are going to use the donations to keep funding in the programs they have in place ..resources, staff …92% of it goes to programs oversees
        • protect the future generations
      • Online / Mail
        • You can donate once or regularly, you can donate small or large amount, anything helps and is greatly appreciated
        • After your journey, send donations to: Catholic Relief Services P.O. Box 17090 Baltimore, MD 21297-0303 or donate online.

“Études has saved us thousands of hours of work and has unlocked insights we never thought possible.”

Annie Steiner

CEO, Greenprint

Join 900+ subscribers

Stay in the loop with everything you need to know.